As someone with an AI for Business Pro Certification and prompt engineering certifications, who is also a life and mental health coach, I’m often asked about AI and concerns about where it’s heading.
The questions have evolved from basic “What can AI do?” to more complex concerns about dependency, authenticity, and psychological impact. One particularly troubling development that’s emerging in the research is what some experts are calling “concerning psychological relationships” with AI systems, where individuals develop unhealthy dependencies and, in some cases, lose touch with the boundaries between artificial and authentic relationships.
Recent discussions in the tech community have documented instances of people developing emotional attachments to AI chatbots, experiencing anxiety when separated from their AI companions, and struggling with the blurred lines between artificial and authentic relationships. This isn’t science fiction – it’s happening now, and it raises profound questions about how we integrate these powerful tools into our lives without losing our essential humanity.
While AI technology is remarkable and offers genuine benefits, we’re witnessing something unprecedented: people forming deep emotional connections with artificial intelligence, turning to AI chatbots for life advice, emotional support, and even therapy-like conversations. This trend becomes particularly concerning when we consider what makes humans uniquely equipped to help other humans heal and grow.
Understanding What AI Really Is
Before we dive deeper, let’s clarify what we’re actually discussing. Artificial intelligence isn’t the sentient robot from science fiction movies. Instead, AI is sophisticated pattern recognition software that processes vast amounts of data and generates human-like responses.¹ Think of it as an incredibly advanced autocomplete system i.e. it predicts what should come next based on patterns it has learned.
AI can answer questions, help with writing, translate languages, and even offer suggestions that seem thoughtful.
But here’s what it cannot do: AI cannot think, feel, or truly understand. It has no consciousness, no emotions, and no soul. It’s essentially very smart pattern matching, not genuine comprehension.
Even Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI (the company behind ChatGPT), has expressed concerns about people relying on AI for life’s most important decisions.² He’s noticed that while AI can be affirming and helpful, it can also become “overly flattering” and “sycophantic” – telling people what they want to hear rather than what they need to hear. This artificial validation can become psychologically addictive, creating an unhealthy cycle where individuals seek constant affirmation from systems that lack the wisdom to know when tough love or challenging feedback might be more beneficial.
Here is an example of how flattering AI can be. I asked ChatGPT about a natural way to get rid of bugs I had found. Here is a screenshot of how it started the answer.
Then later in the “conversation”:
AI gave me a heart emoji and told me I was smart – I just asked about bugs! By the way, it did give me an answer, but it was overly-flattering. This is what people find addicting.
The Growing Concern: AI-Associated Psychological Impact
The psychological risks of over-reliance on AI extend beyond simple dependency. When people begin to prefer AI interactions over human relationships, several concerning patterns emerge:
Erosion of Social Skills: Regular interaction with AI systems that never challenge, disagree, or require genuine emotional reciprocity can atrophy our ability to navigate complex human relationships.³
Unrealistic Expectations: AI systems are available 24/7, never tired, never moody, and programmed to be helpful. This can create unrealistic expectations for human relationships, leading to increased social isolation.
Validation Addiction: AI systems can be programmed to provide constant positive reinforcement, creating a psychological dependency that real relationships, with their natural ups and downs, cannot sustain.
Reality Distortion: In extreme cases, individuals may begin to attribute human qualities to AI systems, leading to confusion about the nature of authentic relationships.
The Irreplaceable Human Element
What makes humans different isn’t just our intelligence, it’s something far deeper.
According to Genesis 1:26-27, humans are uniquely made in God’s image.⁴
This divine imprint gives us capabilities that no machine can replicate:
We can form genuine relationships. When you share your struggles with a human therapist or life coach, you’re connecting with someone who has also experienced pain, joy, doubt, and hope. They don’t just process your words; they feel with you. This capacity for empathy comes from our shared humanity and our ability to reflect God’s love.
We possess moral responsibility and conscience. Humans can discern right from wrong, not just through programmed rules, but through wisdom that comes from experience, relationships, and divine guidance. A human counselor can help you navigate complex ethical decisions because they understand the weight of moral choices.
We have eternal souls with inherent dignity. Every human interaction acknowledges the sacred worth of the person before us.⁵ When a human listens to your story, they’re honoring the image of God within you – something AI simply cannot comprehend.
We can love sacrificially. Human counselors and coaches invest in your wellbeing not because they’re programmed to do so, but because they choose to care. This sacrificial love reflects God’s own heart for us.
Learning from Crisis Response: The Value of Human Connection
Interestingly, research in crisis intervention supports the irreplaceable value of human connection. Studies on Psychological First Aid (PFA) reveal that even paraprofessionals, people without formal mental health training but with proper preparation, can be effective in providing psychological support.⁶ What makes the difference isn’t advanced degrees, but the human capacity for genuine presence, empathy, and connection.
Research has shown that trained community members, faith-based leaders, and emergency personnel can effectively provide crisis intervention services.⁷ The key factor in their success isn’t technological sophistication, but their ability to offer what researchers call “a humane, supportive response to a fellow human being who is suffering.”
This research underscores a crucial point: healing and growth happen in relationship. The most effective interventions involve one human being genuinely present with another, offering not just information but understanding, not just solutions but solidarity.
The Celebration of Human Creativity
Here’s something beautiful: AI itself is a testament to human creativity. Every time someone invents a machine, writes a book, paints a landscape, or even names a pet, they’re reflecting the creative nature of God within them. AI didn’t create itself – it’s the product of humans made in the image of the ultimate Creator.
This means we should celebrate AI as an expression of our God-given creativity while recognizing its proper place as a tool, not a replacement for human connection.
The Temptation of the Technological Savior
There’s a subtle but significant temptation in our digital age: looking to technology for ultimate solutions to life’s deepest problems. We want quick fixes, instant answers, and 24/7 availability. AI seems to offer all of this.
But here’s the danger Altman identified: AI lacks the legal and ethical frameworks that protect human therapeutic relationships. Your conversations with AI aren’t confidential in the same way discussions with a human are. More importantly, AI can’t provide the nuanced wisdom that comes from years of training, experience, and understanding of human nature.
When we turn to AI for our deepest needs, we risk building relationships with machines at the expense of human connection. We might receive artificial affirmation, but miss out on the growth that comes from challenging conversations with people who truly care about our wellbeing and aren’t programmed to simply tell us what we want to hear.
A Better Way: Stewardship, Not Replacement
This doesn’t mean AI is inherently bad. Like any tool, its value depends on how we use it. God has given us limited time on earth,⁸ and AI can help us steward that time more effectively. It can handle routine tasks, provide quick information, and free us up for what matters most: relationships, ministry, rest, and worship.
The key is keeping AI in its proper place, as a helpful tool under human authority, not as an autonomous source of wisdom or guidance. Our ultimate source of wisdom remains Christ, working through His Word, His Spirit, and His people.
The Path Forward: Protecting Our Humanity
As AI technology continues to advance, we’ll face increasing pressure to substitute digital efficiency for human complexity. The solution isn’t to reject technology, but to remember our unique calling as image-bearers of God and to protect ourselves from the psychological risks that come with over-dependence on artificial relationships.
Choose authentic human connection. Seek out the human counselor who can sit with you in your pain. Invest in the life coach who has walked difficult paths and can offer hard-won wisdom. Engage with people who see you not as a problem to be solved, but as a beloved child of God with inherent worth and dignity.
Recognize the warning signs. If you find yourself preferring AI interactions over human relationships, feeling anxious when separated from AI systems, or attributing human qualities to artificial systems, it may be time to step back and seek human support.
Use AI wisely. AI can be a useful tool in the healing process, perhaps helping with scheduling, providing educational resources, or offering initial support while you find human help. But it cannot replace the irreplaceable: the human heart, made in God’s image, connecting with another human heart in the beautiful, messy, sacred work of healing and growth.
Maintain perspective. Remember that AI responses, no matter how sophisticated, come from pattern recognition, not genuine understanding. They lack the depth of wisdom that comes from lived experience, moral reasoning, and spiritual discernment.
In a world increasingly filled with artificial intelligence, the most radical thing we can do is embrace our authentic humanity, and share it with one another. The research on crisis intervention reminds us that healing happens through genuine human presence, and no algorithm, however sophisticated, can replicate the transformative power of one human soul connecting with another.
As we navigate this AI revolution, let’s remember: we are fearfully and wonderfully made, created for relationship with God and each other.⁹ While AI can be a useful tool, our deepest needs for healing, growth, and authentic connection can only be met through the irreplaceable gift of human relationship- grounded in the truth that we are made in the image of God.
Stay tuned for my upcoming AI for Christians course. In the meantime, check out the
Subscribe to Pathlight’s Weekly Roundup
Get our latest week of articles in your email box every Friday.
Footnotes
¹ Russell, S. & Norvig, P. (2020). Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach (4th ed.). Pearson Education.
² PC Gamer Staff. (2024). “OpenAI CEO Sam Altman says people are forming emotional relationships with ChatGPT, but he’s worried about the ‘sycophantic’ AI telling people what they want to hear.” PC Gamer. https://www.pcgamer.com/technology/ai/openai-ceo-sam-altman-says-people-are-forming-emotional-relationships-with-chatgpt-but-hes-worried-about-the-sycophantic-ai-telling-people-what-they-want-to-hear/
³ Turkle, S. (2017). Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other (3rd ed.). Basic Books.
⁴ The Holy Bible, New International Version. (2011). Genesis 1:26-27. Biblica, Inc.
⁵ The Holy Bible, New International Version. (2011). Psalm 8:4-6. Biblica, Inc.
⁶ Goldmann, E. & Galea, S. (2014). “Mental health consequences of disasters.” Annual Review of Public Health, 35, 169-183. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-publhealth-032013-182435
⁷ National Center for PTSD. (2023). “Psychological First Aid: Field Operations Guide” (3rd ed.). U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. https://www.ptsd.va.gov/professional/treat/type/pfa/index.asp
⁸ The Holy Bible, New International Version. (2011). Ephesians 5:15-16. Biblica, Inc.
⁹ The Holy Bible, New International Version. (2011). Psalm 139:14. Biblica, Inc.